Return to blog
November 12, 2026 9 min read

What can you show a prospect that no other agency can?

How to get 14 days on a prospect's website before the pitch and walk in with the companies already looking at them that nobody has called.

Marios Morad
Marios Morad Customer Success Lead
Share
Summarize
What can you show a prospect that no other agency can?

Your prospect is sitting in their third pitch meeting of the week. Slide two is the logo wall, slide three is a process with four steps and a circular arrow. Slide four says “data-driven”. Your deck is next and it has all of those too.

They’re going to pick one of you. If nothing in the room helped them tell you apart, they’ll pick on price or on who they liked. (Neither reason survives the first bad month.)

Every agency brings a deck about itself.

Why not bring the prospect’s own buyers instead? The companies that are already interested, that nobody on their side has called.

Snitcher names the companies visiting a website, form or no form. With 14 days and the prospect’s OK, you can walk into the pitch with names no other agency in that room has.

Why do prospects struggle to tell agencies apart?

Because every pitch is about the agency. Case studies from other markets, results from other budgets, a team page. All of it might be true but the prospect can’t check any of it.

So they compare what they can compare:

What’s in the deckWhat the prospect thinks
Case studiesDifferent market, different budget. Would it work for us?
“3x pipeline for a SaaS client”Compared with what?
Our processEveryone’s process has four steps
The teamNice people. So were the last two agencies.
The priceFinally, something we can compare side-by-side

That last row is how you end up winning on price. A client you win on price is one you’ll lose on price, usually to the next agency with a cheaper deck. (If you’re winning pitches and losing renewals, start with your reports.)

Your work might be better than everyone else’s. The pitch just doesn’t show it because none of it is about them.

What would they actually want to see?

Their own business from a side they can’t see themselves.

Most companies that visit a B2B website never fill in a form. The prospect’s marketing team sees traffic and a handful of enquiries.

So show them three things.

  • Who’s looking: companies on their website in the last two weeks that look like their customers.
  • Who’s been missed: the ones nobody on their side has spoken to.
  • What you’d do about it: what each one read, who to ask for and why now.

That proves you understand their market, not just yours. It also does something a case study can’t. It gives their sales team something to do on Monday, whether they hire you or not.

(Which, fortunately, makes them more likely to hire you.)

How do you get that before you’ve won them?

You ask. There’s no way to see who’s on someone’s website without a script on it, so you need their OK. It’s a smaller ask than it sounds.

Start with your own website. Partners get a free Snitcher account, so put it on your agency’s site first. You’ll see which prospects are reading your case studies and pricing before they get in touch. The pages they read tell you what they care about and the companies tell you who to offer this to.

Then make the ask on the first call.

“Before we send a proposal, give us 14 days with a script on your site. We’ll come back with the companies already looking at you that nobody has called. If the list is useless, you’ve lost nothing.”

It costs them nothing and everyone wants to know who’s on their website.

Expect the same three questions clients ask.

They askWhat to tell them
“We’ve got Google Analytics”It shows how many came from LinkedIn. This shows which companies
”Is this legal?”Snitcher names companies under legitimate interest and the data stays in the EU. Send their legal team this
“Will it catch every visit?”No tool does, whatever they tell you. But Snitcher names far more than the few who fill in a form

Then get three things from them before you hang up.

  • The industries, countries and company sizes they sell to.
  • Their biggest customers and competitors, so those stay off the list.
  • A few companies they’d most like to win.

What do you put in front of them?

One page before the credentials. (Keep the credentials. Just put them after.)

The page has three parts.

  1. One headline line. “In 14 days, 186 companies visited your website and 41 of them look like your customers.”
  2. Five companies worth calling. What they read, who to ask for and why now.
  3. One thing you’d change. Something the list told you about their marketing.

Here’s how the middle part could look for a prospect that sells fleet tracking software:

CompanyWhat they readWho to ask forWhy now
A regional courier firmPricing, twice this weekHead of operationsBack twice in a week and nobody’s been in touch
A facilities management groupIntegrations and the API docsIT leadTechnical pages usually come after the shortlist
A construction supplierA case study about your biggest customerFleet managerSame size and sector as that customer

The third part is your pitch. Something like: “A third of your paid search visits came from universities and job seekers. We’d fix that in the first month.” That’s what you’d do, proven on their own data.

Then ask one question in the room: “Which of these do you know?”

If they don’t know most of them, the other decks stop mattering.

Send the page afterwards, with the best name in the email itself:

If the list is short, say so. Low traffic means they’re not ready for this yet and you’ve both avoided a contract that wouldn’t have worked. If the list is full of the wrong companies, that’s your pitch.

So, what can you show a prospect that no other agency can?

Their own buyers. Every agency in the room can show what it did for someone else. Only the one that asked for 14 days can show who’s already on the prospect’s website and hasn’t been called.

Get the script in with their OK, grade what comes in, pick five names you’d bet on and put that page before your credentials. The conversation moves from your day rate to their buyers.

Once you’ve won them, keep doing it every Monday.

Here’s the whole thing in one table:

WhenWhat you do
Before the first callRun Snitcher on your own site and see which prospects are reading
The first callAsk for 14 days and get their brief
The day the script goes inGrade the companies and leave out customers and competitors
Week twoPick five names and add who to ask for and why now
The pitchOne page first, then ask which of them they know
After the pitchSend the page with the best name in the email

Snitcher finds the companies. You tell the prospect what they mean.

Will Hunt

“Snitcher is a gamechanger. I now have consistent and complete control of all our client accounts.”

AMI logo
Will Hunt Operations lead

Pitching next month? Join the agency program and set up your first prospect today. You’ll have names before the pitch.

What do you think of this page?

Install in minutes

The last thing your team needs is another tool that requires training, so we made one that doesn't.

Start for free